Bakery Location …

We now offer Local Delivery!

Best Cheesecakes in NYC

Celebrate Thanksgiving with our Delicious Pies. Pre-order Today!

  • Filters
  • Sort by
    ...
  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York style apple cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York style apple cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    Apple Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our decadent New York style apple cheesecake infused with fresh apple flavor. This rich, creamy dessert features a buttery graham crust, velvety smooth filling with tender apple pieces, and a generous topping of cinnamon-spiced crumbs. Perfect for special occasions or an elevated everyday treat that satisfies both cheesecake lovers and apple dessert enthusiasts.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    New York Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $65.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our authentic New York cheesecake, featuring a rich, velvety cream cheese filling with a hint of vanilla, perfectly balanced on a buttery graham cracker crust. Each slice delivers the classic dense, yet creamy texture that made this iconic dessert famous. Baked to perfection and ready to satisfy your sweet cravings.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a New York style blueberry cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    Blueberry Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Experience the ultimate dessert delight with our NY-style cheesecake, crowned with a rich blueberry topping. Creamy and decadent, this classic dessert is infused with the sweet-tart essence of fresh blueberries, making it ideal for any celebration. Enjoy the perfect balance of flavors in every mouthwatering bite of this delectable blueberry cheesecake.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a NY-style caramel cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a NY-style caramel cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    Caramel Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Experience the ultimate dessert delight with our New York-style caramel cheesecake! This indulgent treat boasts a creamy, rich cheesecake base drizzled with luscious caramel, creating a perfect harmony of decadent flavors. Enjoy the smooth, melt-in-your-mouth texture of this classic dessert, ideal for any celebration.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York style cherry cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York style cherry cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    Cherry Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our decadent New York style cherry cheesecake, featuring a velvety smooth cream cheese filling perfectly balanced with sweet-tart cherry topping. Each slice offers the classic rich texture and depth of authentic New York cheesecake complemented by premium cherry filling. A divine dessert experience for cheesecake connoisseurs and casual dessert lovers alike.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional oreo cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional oreo cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    Oreo Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our decadent oreo cheesecake, featuring a rich, velvety cream cheese filling studded with crushed oreo cookies atop a chocolatey oreo crust. Each heavenly slice delivers the perfect balance of smooth, creamy texture and iconic cookies-and-cream flavor. A dessert lover’s dream that satisfies sweet cravings with every bite.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York style pecan pie cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional New York style pecan pie cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    ,
    Pecan Pie Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our heavenly pecan pie cheesecake—a luxurious New York style cheesecake perfectly infused with rich chocolate and sweet caramel, crowned with buttery caramelized pecans. This show-stopping dessert combines two classic favorites into one unforgettable treat that’s perfect for special occasions or an indulgent dessert experience.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional strawberry cheesecake at Mia's Bakery.
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional strawberry cheesecake slice at Mia's Bakery.
    , ,
    Strawberry Cheesecake Price range: $56.00 through $68.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our luxurious New York style strawberry cheesecake, featuring a velvety smooth cream cheese filling on a buttery graham cracker crust. Topped with fresh, juicy strawberries and a sweet glaze, this classic dessert balances rich creaminess with bright fruit flavor. Perfect for special occasions or an elegant everyday treat.

Premium New York Style Cheesecakes in NYC

Mia's Bakery specializes in handcrafted New York style cheesecakes, baked fresh daily. We've been serving authentic NYC cheesecakes made with premium cream cheese, farm-fresh ingredients, and traditional graham cracker crusts since we first opened.

Our cheesecake selection includes classic favorites and creative variations. The signature Classic New York Cheesecake delivers the dense, velvety texture that defines traditional NYC style. We also offer Pecan Pie Cheesecake, Oreo Cheesecake, and seasonal flavors, all made with the same commitment to quality ingredients and traditional baking methods.

Cheesecakes Delivered Fresh at NYC

You can order cheesecake online for delivery throughout Manhattan and Brooklyn, with same-day delivery available in most areas. We deliver cheesecakes to all five boroughs, keeping them properly chilled during transport to maintain that perfect creamy texture.

For pickup, visit our three NYC locations in Brooklyn, the Upper East Side, or Times Square. All locations carry our full cheesecake menu, and you can place your order online or call ahead.

Perfect for Any Occasion

Our cheesecakes work for birthdays, corporate events, holidays, or whenever you want authentic New York cheesecake. We bake every cheesecake to order, so what arrives at your door (or what you pick up) is as fresh as possible.

Whether you need a whole cheesecake for a gathering or individual slices for a smaller celebration, ordering cheesecakes online from Mia's Bakery means getting the real NYC experience without leaving your neighborhood.

Filters
My Cart
Categories