Bakery Location …

We now offer Local Delivery!

Fresh Baked Pies NYC

Where Art Meets Pastry

  • Filters
  • Sort by
    ...
  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional apple crumb pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Apple Crumb Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our homestyle apple crumb pie, where orchard-fresh apples mingle with warm cinnamon and nutmeg beneath a buttery, hand-crafted streusel topping. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of tender fruit, flaky crust, and crunchy, golden crumbles. A timeless dessert that brings comfort to any occasion.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional blueberry crumb pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Blueberry Crumb Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our homemade blueberry crumb pie featuring plump, juicy berries in a flaky golden crust, topped with buttery brown sugar streusel. This classic American dessert combines sweet-tart flavor with irresistible cinnamon-spiced crumble topping. Perfect for summer gatherings, holidays, or everyday treats.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional cherry crumb pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Cherry Crumb Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our homemade cherry crumb pie, bursting with juicy, tart cherries nestled beneath a golden, buttery crumb topping. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of sweet and tangy flavors in a flaky, all-butter crust. A timeless dessert favorite for holidays, special occasions, or simple everyday indulgence.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional apple pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Apple Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our homemade golden-brown apple pie, bursting with orchard-fresh apples and warm cinnamon spices beneath a flaky, buttery crust. Perfectly baked to golden perfection, each slice delivers the nostalgic comfort of traditional baking with a delicate balance of sweetness and tartness. A timeless dessert for any occasion.

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional banana cream pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Banana Cream Pie $42.00

    Our homemade banana cream pie features layers of fresh, ripe bananas nestled in velvety vanilla custard, topped with cloud-like whipped cream. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of creamy sweetness and delicate banana flavor in our flaky, buttery crust.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional blueberry pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Blueberry Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Golden-crusted blueberry pie featuring blueberries bursting with sweet-tart flavor. Handcrafted with our signature flaky butter crust and farm-fresh berries, this classic American dessert delivers homemade goodness in every bite. Perfect for holidays, gatherings, or everyday indulgence. Serve warm with vanilla ice cream for the ultimate dessert experience.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional cherry pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Cherry Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our homemade cherry pie, bursting with sweet-tart cherries enveloped in a flaky, golden-brown crust. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of fruity sweetness and buttery pastry. Topped with a signature cherry garnish and sugar glaze, this classic dessert promises to delight your taste buds. Perfect for holidays or everyday treats!

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional key lime pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Chocolate Cream Pie $42.00

    Indulge in our decadent chocolate cream pie featuring luxurious chocolate mousse swirled into an elegant rose pattern atop a crispy chocolate crust. This irresistible dessert combines rich cocoa flavors with silky smooth cream, creating the perfect sweet ending to any meal. Handcrafted daily for ultimate freshness and taste.

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional coconut pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Coconut Pie $38.00

    Escape to tropical paradise with our heavenly coconut pie, featuring a silky custard filling infused with sweet coconut shavings and baked to golden perfection. This classic Southern dessert delivers creamy, dreamy coconut flavor in every forkful. An irresistible treat that’s perfect for holidays, celebrations, or satisfying your sweet tooth anytime!

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional key lime pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Key Lime Pie $38.00

    Indulge in our tangy-sweet key lime pie, featuring a velvety smooth filling bursting with authentic key lime flavor atop a buttery graham cracker crust. Finished with delicate whipped cream lattice, this refreshing dessert balances zesty citrus and creamy sweetness. The perfect treat for any occasion.

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional pecan pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Pecan Pie $42.00

    Indulge in our homemade pecan pie, featuring a golden, flaky crust filled with rich, caramelized filling and topped with premium crunchy pecans. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of sweetness and nutty flavor. A classic Southern dessert ideal for holidays, special occasions, or satisfying your sweet tooth anytime.

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional pumpkin pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Pumpkin Pie $38.00

    Indulge in our handcrafted pumpkin pie, featuring a velvety, spice-infused filling nestled in a flaky, golden crust. Each pie is topped with fresh whipped cream and baked to perfection using premium ingredients. The ideal centerpiece for holiday gatherings or a delightful seasonal treat for any occasion.

  • Add to cart
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional sweet potato pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Sweet Potato Pie $38.00

    Indulge in our homemade sweet potato pie, featuring a buttery, flaky crust with elegant lattice design. Rich, velvety sweet potato filling blends with warm spices and a touch of vanilla. Topped with fresh whipped cream for a delightful southern classic that’s perfect for holidays or everyday treats.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional triple berry crumb pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Triple Berry Crumb Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our handcrafted triple berry pie featuring a buttery golden crust filled with juicy strawberries, blueberries, and blackberries. Topped with a generous cinnamon-spiced crumb streusel and dusted with powdered sugar. This homestyle dessert delivers the perfect balance of sweet-tart berry flavors in every bite.

  • Select options
    savor the classic flavor of a traditional triple berry pie at Mia's Bakery.
    Triple Berry Pie $29.00 – $38.00
    Select Size
    8" (Serves 8-10)10" (Serves 12-15)

    Indulge in our heavenly triple berry pie, bursting with plump strawberries, juicy blueberries, and tangy raspberries under a golden, flaky crust. Each slice delivers the perfect balance of sweet-tart flavor and buttery pastry. Handcrafted with fresh, seasonal berries and no artificial preservatives. The ultimate berry dessert experience!

The Best Pies in NYC, Handcrafted Daily

When you're searching for authentic pies NYC has to offer, Mia's Bakery delivers the perfect blend of traditional recipes and artisan quality. Our bakery creates fresh pies daily using premium ingredients and time-honored techniques that have made us a local favorite across Manhattan, Brooklyn, and beyond.

Why Choose Mia's for Your NYC Pie Cravings

Handcrafted Excellence: Every pie starts with our signature all-butter crust, rolled fresh each morning. We source the finest ingredients ensuring each bite delivers exceptional flavor. Brooklyn Tradition: Located in the heart of Brooklyn with locations in Manhattan's Upper East Side and Times Square, we bring authentic New York bakery tradition to every pie we create. Same-Day Delivery: Need pies today? We deliver fresh pies across NYC seven days a week, from 9 AM to 9 PM, covering Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx.

Our Most Popular NYC Pies

Classic Fruit Pies: Our apple pie features orchard-fresh apples with warm cinnamon spices in a flaky, golden crust. The blueberry pie bursts with sweet-tart flavor, while our triple berry combines strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries for the ultimate fruit experience. Cream Pies: The chocolate cream pie showcases luxurious chocolate mousse in an elegant rose pattern, and our banana cream pie layers fresh bananas with velvety vanilla custard. Holiday Favorites: From pumpkin and pecan to sweet potato and key lime, we create seasonal pies that make every celebration special.

Fresh Pies Delivered Across NYC

Whether you're planning a family gathering in Brooklyn, need dessert for a Manhattan office party, or want to surprise someone special, our NYC pie delivery service brings bakery-fresh quality right to your door. Each pie is carefully packaged to maintain freshness and arrives ready to serve. Delivery Areas: Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Bronx Store Locations: Brooklyn (139 Smith St), Upper East Side (1573 3rd Avenue), Times Square (716 7th Ave)

Order Your Perfect Pie Today

From classic apple to decadent chocolate cream, Mia's Bakery creates the pies NYC residents have trusted for years. Browse our complete selection and taste the difference that fresh, quality ingredients make.
Filters
My Cart
Categories